Shelby Anderson saw action in three seasons for the Lindenwood baseball team from 2009-2011 and was a regular starter for his final two seasons. He was a two-time first-team All-HAAC selection, was the 2011 HAAC Player of the Year, and was a 2011 an honorable mention All-American.
 
For his career, Anderson had a .376 batting average and a .685 slugging percentage. He recorded over 100 runs and RBIs and hit 24 home runs.